openbeacon
Jul 06, 2026

The Bee Gees Wrote This Song for Otis Redding — But He Never Got to Record It

In 1967, the Bee Gees were still newcomers trying to establish themselves outside Australia.

Barry, Robin and Maurice Gibb had arrived in Britain with enormous ambition, but they were far from the global superstars they would eventually become.

Then their manager, Robert Stigwood, gave them an unusual assignment.

Write a song for Otis Redding.

At the time, Redding was one of the most powerful soul singers in America. His voice could turn almost any lyric into something urgent and deeply personal.

Barry and Robin Gibb began writing with that kind of voice in mind.

The result was “To Love Somebody.”

It was very different from the disco music that would make the Bee Gees famous a decade later. The song moved with the feeling of American soul — slow, aching and built around a simple declaration of love that sounds almost painful in its intensity.

The brothers hoped Otis Redding might record it.

But before that happened, the Bee Gees recorded the song themselves for their 1967 album Bee Gees’ 1st.

Barry sang the lead.

Robin and Maurice surrounded him with the harmonies that were already becoming the brothers’ trademark.

The recording became one of the earliest signs that the Bee Gees could do far more than British-style pop.

They understood soul.

They understood longing.

And Barry’s performance gave the song an emotional vulnerability that would remain one of its defining qualities.

“To Love Somebody” reached No. 17 on the Billboard Hot 100 in America.

But the story soon took a tragic turn.

On December 10, 1967, Otis Redding was killed when the small plane carrying him and members of his touring band crashed into a Wisconsin lake.

He was only 26.

The singer the Bee Gees had imagined for “To Love Somebody” would never make his own recording of it.

Yet the song kept traveling.

Over the decades, artists from completely different musical worlds recorded their own versions.

Nina Simone transformed it into something intensely personal.

Janis Joplin brought raw blues-rock emotion to it.

Rod Stewart, Michael Bolton and many others later discovered the same thing:

The song did not belong to one voice or one era.

Perhaps that was because Barry and Robin had accidentally written something much bigger than a song for another singer.

They had written about a feeling almost everyone eventually understands — loving someone so deeply that words never seem quite enough.

Other posts